Capture every guest, with permission
Your POS, website ordering, reservations, and gift card sales all touch guests. Each should collect an email or phone number with clear permission and send it into one database the restaurant owns.
What the marketing numbers say
Toast's Q1 2026 data found that among restaurants using these tools, 86% of email-driven orders and 83% of SMS-driven orders came from repeat guests. Email and text are how regulars hear from you.
DoorDash says its Direct automated email campaigns increase order frequency by an average of 15% among new and returning customers. That is a DoorDash Direct product claim, not independent research.
One case study, via Olo, describes California Fish Grill: guests who opted in to SMS visited 46% more often, with 4% higher average order value and 69% higher lifetime value. That is one restaurant brand, not an industry average, but it shows what a well-run program can look like.
Texting rules matter
Marketing text messages require documented opt-in. Keep a record of when and how each guest agreed, honor opt-outs immediately, and send fewer, better messages.
Practical recommendations
- Add an opt-in checkbox at online checkout and on reservation forms
- Invite in-person guests to join with a table card or receipt link
- Send a welcome message, a birthday note, and a "we miss you" offer
- Segment by behavior: catering clients, families, weekday lunch regulars
- Measure orders and visits, not just opens
Sources
- Toast, restaurant loyalty program return rate (Q1 2026 data)
- DoorDash, email automation for restaurants, DoorDash Direct product claim
- California Fish Grill, via Olo: why SMS marketing matters for restaurants, Single-restaurant case study