The list
- Update the website and menu. 80% look at your site and 85% look at the menu first (TouchBistro, 2024).
- Add direct ordering and scheduled pickup. 56% leave if they cannot order online (Popmenu, 2023), and pre-scheduling was the top requested takeout innovation (TouchBistro, 2024).
- Move repeat guests off marketplaces when they will order direct. 84% of off-premises customers say they would order on your website (NRA Restaurant Technology Trends Report, 2024).
- Put reservations, parties, and catering on the site, with deposits for big nights. Deposits cut no-shows by 57% on average (OpenTable platform figure).
- Sell gift cards. December is about 31% of annual volume (Paytronix, 2026).
- Enroll guests into a permission-based list and loyalty program. Enrollment can move return rate from 7% to nearly 30% (Toast, Q1 2026).
- Use email and opt-in SMS to invite people back. Most email- and SMS-driven orders come from repeat guests (Toast, Q1 2026).
- Ask for, and reply to, reviews. 79% say reviews affect their decision (US Foods, 2023).
- Plan midweek catering and holiday seatings. About 37% of 2024 catering orders came in the last quarter (Toast, Q4 2024).
Where to start
Pick the gap that is most visible to guests. For most independents, that is the website and menu. Then add one revenue path at a time: ordering, then gift cards, then parties and catering, with a guest list underneath all of it.
Sources
- TouchBistro 2024 American Diner Trends Report
- Popmenu, 6 things diners wish restaurant owners knew about online ordering, 2023
- National Restaurant Association, Restaurant Technology Trends Report 2024 (summarized March 28, 2024)
- OpenTable, 3 proven payment strategies to reduce no-shows, OpenTable platform figures
- Paytronix Gift Card Report 2026, Paytronix platform data for $5, $10, $25, and $50 restaurant cards
- Toast, restaurant loyalty program return rate (Q1 2026 data)
- US Foods, American menu choices survey, 2023
- Toast, holiday parties and catering trends (Q4 2024, published March 6, 2025)