What a Modern Restaurant Website Needs
A practical checklist, from the menu to gift cards to rewards, with the research behind each item.
A restaurant website has more jobs than it used to. It is the menu, the host stand, the order counter, the gift shop, and the guest list. This checklist covers what a modern site needs, with the research behind each item.
1. A real menu
85% of diners look at the menu online before choosing a new restaurant (TouchBistro, 2024). 83% review the menu before going, and half of them already know what they will order (US Foods, 2023). Write it in text, with prices and descriptions. Avoid PDFs: 49% of guests will leave if they hit one on mobile (Popmenu, 2023).
2. Food photos
66% of diners prefer menus with photos (Toast, 2024 survey). Start with signature dishes and keep photos current.
3. Hours and location
The most basic information is also the most important. Put hours, address, and a map link on the home page, and update holiday hours early.
4. A clear order button
84% of off-premises customers would order on a restaurant's website (NRA Restaurant Technology Trends Report, 2024). Popmenu found 56% leave if they cannot order online. One obvious "Order" button on every page, leading to your own ordering.
5. Scheduled pickup
Pre-scheduling pickup or delivery was the top takeout innovation diners wanted (23%, TouchBistro 2024). Let guests order now for Thursday at 7.
6. Reservations and parties
A booking button on every page, and a private events page with an inquiry form. For big nights, use deposits: OpenTable platform figures show deposits cut no-show rates by 57% on average.
7. Catering
If you cater, give it its own page with packages, lead times, and a request form.
8. Gift cards
Sell physical and e-gift cards online. December is about 31% of annual gift card volume (Paytronix, 2026).
9. Login and rewards
Guest accounts, saved favorites, and loyalty make reordering easy. Toast's Q1 2026 data found enrollment can move return rate from 7% to nearly 30%.
10. A way to join the list
An email sign-up and opt-in text option, so guests can hear about new menus and events.
11. Beverage menu
67% of guests are more likely to visit or order if the beverage menu is online (Popmenu, 2023).
12. A current design
An older MGH survey (2019) found nearly 70% of diners who visit restaurant websites had been discouraged by one, and 30% said the site looked old or out of date. Design is part of hospitality.
How to use this checklist
Go through your own site on a phone. Mark each item as done, partly done, or missing. Fix the missing items that guests see first: menu, hours, and the order button. Then add the revenue paths: gift cards, parties, catering, and loyalty.
Practical takeaways
- Treat the website as a revenue tool, not a brochure.
- Fix menu, hours, and ordering first.
- Add gift cards before the holidays.
- Connect ordering, reservations, gift cards, and loyalty to one guest list.
- Review the site every quarter.
Read the Websites and Design guide or estimate your own gap on the Money Left on the Table page.
Common mistakes to avoid
Fixing the design but not the paths
A beautiful site that still has no ordering, booking, or gift cards looks better but leaves the same gaps. Pair design work with the revenue paths.
Adding features no one can find
A gift card page or catering form only helps if guests can see it from the home page and the menu. Link to each one clearly.
Too many pop-ups
One gentle invitation to join your list is fine. Several pop-ups stacked on top of the menu push guests away.
Slow pages
Large uncompressed photos and heavy add-ons slow a site on mobile data. Guests waiting for a page to load are guests deciding to look elsewhere.
Not checking it like a guest
Once a quarter, ask someone outside the business to order, book, and buy a gift card on your site while you watch. Their hesitations will show you what to fix next.
Questions owners ask
Where should I start if my site is missing most of these?
Start with what every guest sees: the menu, hours, and a clear order button. Then add gift cards before the holidays, followed by parties, catering, and loyalty.
Do I need a new website or just updates?
If the site is hard to update, slow on phones, or cannot connect to ordering and gift cards, a rebuild may be simpler than patching.
How do I know if the design looks dated?
Compare it with the restaurants guests are choosing instead of you. If yours looks older, guests notice too.
How long should a homepage be?
Long enough to show the food, the room, and the main actions, and short enough to scan on a phone in under a minute.
Citations
- TouchBistro 2024 American Diner Trends Report
- US Foods, American menu choices survey, 2023
- Toast QR code and menu survey, 2024
- Popmenu, 6 things diners wish restaurant owners knew about online ordering, 2023
- National Restaurant Association, Restaurant Technology Trends Report 2024 (summarized March 28, 2024)
- OpenTable, 3 proven payment strategies to reduce no-shows, OpenTable platform figures
- Paytronix Gift Card Report 2026, Paytronix platform data for $5, $10, $25, and $50 restaurant cards
- Toast, restaurant loyalty program return rate (Q1 2026 data)
- MGH survey, 2019, via Restaurant Dive (August 30, 2019), Older survey
Keep reading
Gift Cards
Gift Cards: Money in the Bank Before the Guest Sits Down
Restaurant gift card revenue grew 18.3% in Paytronix's latest report, and December carries about a third of the year.
Teresa Gonzalez, Restaurant Expert · November 12, 2026
Online Ordering
What Third-Party Delivery Really Costs, and What Changes When Guests Order from You
The official commission ladders from DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub, compared with first-party processing, plus the cost nobody prints.
Teresa Gonzalez, Restaurant Expert · November 9, 2026
Websites and Design
How a Basic Restaurant Website Loses Guests Before They Walk In
Most new guests visit your website before they visit your dining room. Here is how a dated site quietly sends them somewhere else.
Teresa Gonzalez, Restaurant Expert · November 2, 2026