Guests are willing to order direct
The National Restaurant Association's Restaurant Technology Trends Report 2024 found that among off-premises customers, 84% would place orders using a restaurant's website, and 71% would also likely use a third-party service. That is a measure of willingness, not current behavior. The same research makes the point that if guests cannot access, order, customize, and pay on a phone or computer, they will order somewhere else.
Popmenu's 2023 survey found 76% prefer ordering on the restaurant's own website, and 56% will go to another restaurant if they cannot order online. NCR Voyix's 2025 report, based on a November 2024 survey, found 58% prefer a restaurant's own app or website for delivery (29% app, 29% website). Their reasons: convenience (65%), customization (50%), and loyalty points (36%).
Scheduled pickup, in plain language
TouchBistro's 2024 report found 72% of diners prefer ordering takeout directly from the restaurant, and the number one takeout innovation they asked for was the option to pre-schedule pickup or delivery (23%).
Scheduled pickup means a guest can open your site on Monday, order dinner, and choose Thursday at 7 for pickup. The kitchen sees it in advance, the guest gets a reminder, and the order is ready when they walk in. It fits office lunches, family dinners, game nights, and holidays. We do not have a sourced figure for how much it lifts sales, so we will not invent one. It simply removes a reason for a guest to go elsewhere.
What the marketplaces charge
Official U.S. marketplace rates, checked November 2026. These are separate plans, not one average.
- DoorDash delivery: Basic 15%, Plus 25%, Premier 30% of subtotal. Pickup is 6% if prices match in-store. DoorDash's own website ordering product is commission-free plus processing.
- Uber Eats delivery: Lite 20%, Plus 25% (plus 5% more on Uber One member orders), Premium 30%. Pickup is 7% with validated in-store pricing, otherwise 10%. Webshop is 2.5% + $0.29 per order.
- Grubhub: published marketing commissions of 5% and 15%, plus a separate delivery fee starting at 10% when using Grubhub drivers. Rates do not include payment processing.
For comparison, Stripe's standard U.S. online card rate is 2.9% + 30 cents per transaction. You can run your own numbers on the Money Left on the Table calculator.
The guest data question
Commission is the visible cost. The quieter cost is the relationship. Olo CEO Noah Glass, quoted in Restaurant Dive on January 30, 2025, pointed out that marketplace orders often leave the restaurant without a usable guest profile for later marketing. That is his view as an industry executive, not a published marketplace rule, but it matches what many operators describe.
Practical recommendations
- Put a prominent "Order" button on every page that goes to your own ordering
- Offer scheduled pickup with clear time slots
- Keep marketplaces for discovery, and invite repeat guests to order direct
- Ask for permission to email or text at checkout
- Print your website on bags and receipts
Sources
- National Restaurant Association, Restaurant Technology Trends Report 2024 (summarized March 28, 2024)
- Popmenu, 6 things diners wish restaurant owners knew about online ordering, 2023
- NCR Voyix 2025 report (November 2024 survey), via Restaurant Dive, January 30, 2025
- TouchBistro 2024 American Diner Trends Report
- DoorDash Merchant pricing (checked November 2026)
- Uber Eats Merchant pricing (checked November 2026)
- Grubhub pricing and fees (checked November 2026)
- Stripe U.S. pricing (checked November 2026)
- Restaurant Dive, January 30, 2025, quoting Olo CEO Noah Glass