Email and Text Are How You Invite People Back
Most email- and SMS-driven orders come from repeat guests. Here is how to use both well, and within the rules.
A guest had a great dinner last month. They meant to come back. Life got busy. A short, well-timed message is often all it takes to turn that intention into a reservation or an order.
Who responds to email and text
Toast's Q1 2026 data found that among restaurants using these tools, 86% of email-driven orders and 83% of SMS-driven orders came from repeat guests. In other words, email and text are primarily how you stay in touch with people who already know you.
What vendors and case studies report
Two figures are worth knowing, with clear labels.
A product claim
DoorDash says its Direct automated email campaigns increase order frequency by an average of 15% among new and returning customers. That is a DoorDash Direct product claim, not independent research.
One restaurant's results
A case study published via Olo describes California Fish Grill. Guests who opted in to SMS visited 46% more often, with 4% higher average order value and 69% higher lifetime value. That is one restaurant brand, not an industry average. It shows what is possible, not what is typical.
We do not repeat generic claims about text message open rates that circulate without a clear source.
The rules for texting
Marketing text messages require documented opt-in. In practice:
- Ask clearly, for example with an unchecked box that says what guests will receive
- Keep a record of when and how each guest opted in
- Include a simple way to opt out in every message, and honor it immediately
- Send at reasonable hours and at a reasonable frequency
Email has its own rules too, including a clear unsubscribe link and an honest sender name.
Messages that work
Welcome
Sent after the first order or sign-up. Thank the guest and invite a second visit.
Birthday
A small treat with a simple redemption window.
We miss you
Triggered when a regular has not visited in a set period.
What is new
New menu items, seasonal specials, and events.
Holiday reminders
Gift cards, catering, and holiday seatings, sent early.
Email or text?
Email is good for richer content: photos, menus, stories, and events. Text is good for short, timely notes: a reminder, a same-day special, or a pickup confirmation. Many restaurants use email as the main channel and save text for guests who opt in and for messages that are genuinely time-sensitive.
Measure what matters
Opens and clicks are useful, but the real measures are orders, reservations, and visits that follow a message. Track them, and send fewer messages if results drop.
Practical takeaways
- Build your list with clear permission at every touchpoint.
- Set up welcome, birthday, and "we miss you" automations first.
- Use text sparingly, only with documented opt-in.
- Label every message honestly and make opting out easy.
- Measure orders and visits, not just opens.
See the Guest Data guide.
Common mistakes to avoid
Sending too often
Frequent messages train guests to ignore you or opt out. A steady, useful rhythm beats a flood.
Every message is a discount
Constant discounts can teach guests to wait for a deal. Mix in stories, new dishes, events, and simple thank-yous.
Generic messages to everyone
A catering client and a weekend brunch regular want different things. Even simple groups make messages feel more relevant.
Texting without clear consent
Marketing texts require documented opt-in. When in doubt, do not send the text until you have clear permission on record.
Not testing on a phone
Most messages are read on a phone. Check how each email looks on a small screen before you send it.
Questions owners ask
How often should I email?
Many restaurants find a few times a month works well. Watch unsubscribes and orders, and adjust.
Should I text every guest?
Only guests who have clearly opted in to texts, and only for messages worth the interruption.
What should my first automation be?
A welcome message for new sign-ups. It is simple, timely, and sets the tone for everything after.
Do I need to write long emails?
No. A strong photo, two or three short sentences, and one clear button often work better than a long newsletter.
Citations
- Toast, restaurant loyalty program return rate (Q1 2026 data)
- DoorDash, email automation for restaurants, DoorDash Direct product claim
- California Fish Grill, via Olo: why SMS marketing matters for restaurants, Single-restaurant case study
Keep reading
Websites and Design
What a Modern Restaurant Website Needs
A practical checklist, from the menu to gift cards to rewards, with the research behind each item.
Teresa Gonzalez, Restaurant Expert · November 16, 2026
Gift Cards
Gift Cards: Money in the Bank Before the Guest Sits Down
Restaurant gift card revenue grew 18.3% in Paytronix's latest report, and December carries about a third of the year.
Teresa Gonzalez, Restaurant Expert · November 12, 2026
Online Ordering
What Third-Party Delivery Really Costs, and What Changes When Guests Order from You
The official commission ladders from DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub, compared with first-party processing, plus the cost nobody prints.
Teresa Gonzalez, Restaurant Expert · November 9, 2026